Pain experiences · Patient experiences

Eric S. Millstein, MD.
Pain experiences reviews.

54 five-star reviews for Dr. Eric S. Millstein discuss pain experiences. Patients describe Dr. Millstein as caring, knowledgeable and kind. Their stories also speak to compassionate care and clear explanations. Read their words, learn what mattered to them, and bring the questions that matter to you to your next visit.

Read the full patient accounts and original sources below. Review totals reflect the source ratings available here.

Read this page as Markdown

Eric S. Millstein, MD

A person behind your care

Get to know
Eric S. Millstein.

Dr. Eric Millstein is a board-certified, fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeon and co-founder of Commons Clinic, where he helps lead a new, more connected model of musculoskeletal care. He specializes in total joint replacement of the knee and shoulder, as well as sports medicine and arthroscopic surgery, including ACL reconstruction, rotator cuff repair, and joint preservation. Known for delivering excellent outcomes and faster recoveries, Dr. Millstein combines surgical expertise with a personal, attentive style that makes patients feel truly cared for.

Patients describe him as kind, clear, and highly skilled—someone who listens first, explains thoroughly, and guides them through the recovery process with confidence. His team is equally known for their warmth and professionalism, creating a care experience that’s both top-tier and deeply human.

Outside the OR, Dr. Millstein is a dedicated dad to two teenagers, and likes to stay active—often on the basketball court or ski slopes.

Total Knee ReplacementPartial Knee ReplacementTotal Shoulder ReplacementReverse Total ShoulderKnee ArthroscopyShoulder Arthroscopy

Meet Eric S. Millstein at Commons Clinic ↗

Bring what matters to you

Your questions
belong in the conversation.

Read what our patients share about pain experiences. Each clinician section brings together accounts that mention this subject, so you can explore the details and follow the source.

  • What matters most to me about the care experience?
  • Which details in these patient accounts would I like to ask our team about?

In their own words

Care feels personal.
So do these stories.

These are individual experiences. A topic mention does not establish who performed a procedure, medical suitability or a typical result.

This collection shows written reviews rated 4 or 5 stars that mention pain experiences. You can read every rating and written review on the full clinician profile.

55 written reviews

Highest rated first · Newest within each rating

Dr. Millstein saw me on time, was thorough in his examination of my troublesome knee and offered suggestions for how to mitigate my pain. He also said that if I didn't find adequate relief, he would approve an MRI should I want one.
GR
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Milstein operated on my left wrist that had broken , back in 2016. excellent surgeon, excellent recovery and no pain afterwards . so after fracturing my left patella i made appt to see him again .He is the only orthopedic doctor i feel comfortable with.. His office staff are all kind , professional . He truly gave me hope , professional , kind and easy for me to explain what happened . i know i will be in good hands after he sees my MRI and goes from there .
RB
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

To begin with the staff was wonderful. His new office space is modern and spacious. It was also impressive that Dr Millistein has a technician on site for X-rays. Dr. Millstein is amazing doctor. He did my right knee about a year ago and it’s in fantastic condition. I tell people it’s biotic. Lol. I’m scheduled to do my left knee in a few months and looking forward to be able to do more activities without any pain. Thank you Dr milstein and staff.
LR
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein is an excellent doctor who explains both surgical and non-surgical options for my arthritic knee pain.
CP
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I so appreciated that I was able to see Dr. Millstein himself to discuss my knee concerns. I had previously tried to see another top knee surgeon and was "blown off" by his Physician's Assistant. Dr. Millstein thoroughly discussed options for my old shattered kneecap injury and how to live my best life pain-free. His conservative approach meant I didn't need knee replacement surgery at this point. He and his staff are kind and caring and I will continuing treatment with him as needed.
SG
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I went in with a lot of right knee pain as a result of a fall on a hike. I had had an MRI but was scared and worried damage had been done. Dr Millstein appeared and went over results, fluid around the area from trauma. Gave me 2 injections and said it would take 4 months to heal. Nothing was torn nor broken. This was a relief. He was calming and professional, said he had experienced a similar injury, and assured me it will heal And pain will lessen. It is getting better. Thank goodness for modern medicine and Dr Millstein!
MI
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I have had the pleasure of being a patient of Dr. Millstein since 2023. He has improved my quality of life immensely. I’m 67 years old and have bad knees. With Dr. Millstein’s recommendation of physical therapy along with cortisone injections I am able to function without pain. He is so kind and considerate, extremely knowledgeable! I highly recommend him! Do not hesitate to reach out to his staff for any questions you might have. They are all great! Make an appointment today and start enjoying your life with less pain and more joy. If I could rate him higher than 5 stars I would. 💫
AR
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Just had my visit with Dr.millstein, he was very professional, explained why I have pain and helped me understand my options. The whole staff was very friendly and his office is beautiful! Feel very lucky that I chose his office.
FT
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein is personable, knowledgeable, practical and efficient. He explained the shoulder pain came from bone on bone caused by arthritis. He treated me with a cortisone shot which has made a world of difference. We have a treatment plan for the future and I feel comfortable that he will be a good partner in helping me keep active.
GJ
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I had a problem with my knee for nine months, and had been seeing another orthopedic surgeon who had misdiagnosed me. Luckily, I had the good sense to obtain a second opinion from Dr. Millstein. Dr. Millstein made a diagnosis in literally two minutes, and my knee was operated on about two weeks later. After nine months of walking with extreme pain in my right knee, I obtained complete relief in a very short period of time. Extremely grateful to be able to walk without pain, and extremely grateful to this excellent doctor, who did not even need to obtain any imaging studies whatsoever to make my diagnosis. As a doctor myself, my advice for anyone out there who is experiencing frustration with their doctors's diagnosis is to obtain a second opinion! Not all doctors know what the hell they're doing. And with medicine getting busier and crazier than ever before, and insurance companies less and less willing to pay for tests, outstanding doctors such as Dr. Millstein are becoming more and more crucial.
BK
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein and staff all were attentive. l appreciate Dr. taking time to listening to my concerns of wild pain and weirdness my shoulder been actively showing. We did find the issue. I will be making another appointment soon at his new office. l am comfortable with him and if surgery is needed l trust him 99% than my own pain management. I am grateful to be and patient of his and staff.
JH
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I had a cortisone shot in my shoulder and I’ve no pain since. Thank you Dr Millstein
BS
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein and his office staff were very professional and helpful. He not only looked at the problem I was seeing him for but my overall recent health issues. Quickly decided on the less evasive treatment . Afterwards I felt so relieved and the pain was almost gone. Ive already recommended him to a friend
TK
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

This office and Dr Millstein are fantastic. What a great experience all the way around.No pain, lots of Smiles annd attentive service.!! Experienced, thoughtful and seemed very caring. A must see specialist Highly recommended.
ML
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I fell on a treadmill that stopped while going around 6.8 mph on an 14.5 incline and slammed hard and fast onto a wood floor. I broke my shoulder, dislocated it, and caused a rotator tear. I waited several weeks for the appointment and drove from the Valley. This was a trek that seemed worth it. Now in retrospect was likely a fair amount of one reviews (questionable ratings). Dr Millstein is nice enough but that does not make a great doctor. He spent less than three minutes with me. There was almost no exam except for 'hold your arm out.' Then he announced the diagnosis of frozen shoulder and proceeded to offer me steroids. I had a tumor history so he then said I could not have this until I got clearance from my doctor. I appreciated that taking that caution, but I would also like to think an MD would know that Glios and brain tumors in this category are the only tumors that are exacerbated by steroids/Cortisones). You would think a doctor would know that. My neurotologist said as much. Additionally, I asked about a Cortisone shot vs steroids. First, he said no to the shot then he flip flopped. I want a doctor to tell me with absolution what I need. This should not be a pick and choose like a pair of shoes with a patient. This is why I drove out of my way. Additionally, he told me to call the doctor myself. I never heard of a doctor telling the patient to call and ask their doctor. Normal protocol is a staff member gets the doctors' info and then communicates with the doctor or gets them on the line with the doctor needing the information (I have a fair number of doctors in my family). I could have not bothered and said it's fine and just had the shot or meds, but I didn't. I was assured that I could be fit in the following week if I had to come back. Thanksgiving weekend was two days later so I had to wait until the following week. I proceeded to call five days after that visit only to be told it would be another two weeks. They offered me a slot that day but there was no way I could get there otherwise it was another two weeks. No accommodations were made and then it's another trip, visit, and more unnecessary nonsense in addition to weeks more pain, but I think it was a lesson learned because he is not the right doctor for me. I sent my info to a surgeon that treats top sports teams, and he offered a non-surgical procedure. Was this even mentioned in that 2.5-minute visit...nope! In conclusion: this doctor does not respect other peoples' time and seems a bit too speedy with the very limited offered care in the visit.
CC
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein is very caring, patient and knowledgeable. A true expert in his field. He explained in detail the source of my knee pain that was coming from my hip. He gave me an injection and delivered treatment options with clarity. I highly recommend him to anyone who suffers with knee, hip and back pain.
SA
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein and his staff are amazing. They really understand how to treat a patient. I've had my knee replaced and am back on the Tennis Courts beating people half my age. Dr. Millstein did an amazing job. He starts with best non invasive approach to help including physical therapy and then suggest other treatments only as needed. If you need a cortisone injection Dr. Millstein is the best at hitting the ‘right spot.’ Everyone there is very organized, I’ve never waited long. I’m very happy with their treatment and would recommend them to anyone having Orthopedic issues and pain.
RR
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Everyone in the office is very helpful and professional. Dr. Millstein is just the best. He performed a reversed shoulder replacement on my right shoulder 3 months ago and I have no pain. Still in therapy for range of motion and strengthening. So happy and thankful with the results.
JB
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Taking a moment to say "Thanks so much" to Dr Eric Millstein and staff for getting me in for a same-day appt!!!! Dr Millstein is a really great doctor... I'm not in pain this morning
KE
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Milstein is very kind, a good listener, and gave me a good plan to help resolve my pain. I am very glad I found a great orthopedic doctor
MA
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Although I haven't seen Dr. Millstein yet and I'm literally just sitting in the waiting room, I had to share my experience thus far with this unbelievable office. Three days ago I fell and broke my wrists, collarbone and a rib. After a quick ER visit, I was told to find an orthopedic specialist to determine what to do next. I called every office around Venice and unfortunately was rejected by all of them because "we don't take new patients at the moment"... I explained that I'm in incredible pain but no luck. Until I called Dr. Eric Millstein's office! The reception ladies were the sweetest and understood my situation and made a true effort to get me in ASAP. Insurance, payments and other items were far from being a priority. I felt like they genuinely wanted to help. The intake form portal and X-ray uploading platform were very user-friendly and it took me less than 5 min to complete it all. They booked me an appointment a week out but kept on updating me on cancellations. A day later a Susie answered my call and was able to squeeze me in to see the Dr. (I can't even describe to you how sweet and helpful this woman is!!) Schevobnn checked me in with the outmost professionalism and I'm currently waiting for the Dr. Highly recommended
HM
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein was a referral and a very good one .. Very smooth and professional from front desk to the good Dr Millstein. He requested further tests and I was appreciative that he was searching for the cause of my pain and scheduled further testing as the reasons were not obvious. 🤞
SH
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

After a year of PT for my left knee , I could not walk anymore . I was recommended to Dr. Milstein & he had to do surgery on my left knee , I walked out of the surgery center with no pain, and 5 years later I’m pain free on that knee. Today I had to see him for my right knee. He saw me on time, attentive to my questions and explained to me clearly , the choices I have to heal that knee. I would definitely recommend Dr. Milstein.
RS
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Would give this guy 100 stars if I could! Was referred by both one of my best friends and my son who is an insurance defense lawyer who uses both drs Kaye and Millstein as their ortho experts. Had rotator cuff surgery and was expecting the worst, given all of the people I talked to who had the same procedure done. Couldn't have been easier. Little pain and discomfort, but that should be expected why you get high quality care. Dr. Millstein was out of network but paid his fee in cash happily. I'm playing golf this weekend, 14 weeks post surgery. Dr. Millstein's CV is ridiculous, as are his doctor and surgical skills.
CG
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

A little more understanding

Feel ready for
your next conversation.