Knee replacement · Patient experiences
17 five-star reviews for Dr. Eric S. Millstein discuss knee replacement. Patients describe Dr. Millstein as great. Their stories also speak to compassionate care and helpful staff. Read their words, learn what mattered to them, and bring the questions that matter to you to your next visit.
Read the full patient accounts and original sources below. Review totals reflect the source ratings available here.
A person behind your care
Dr. Eric Millstein is a board-certified, fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeon and co-founder of Commons Clinic, where he helps lead a new, more connected model of musculoskeletal care. He specializes in total joint replacement of the knee and shoulder, as well as sports medicine and arthroscopic surgery, including ACL reconstruction, rotator cuff repair, and joint preservation. Known for delivering excellent outcomes and faster recoveries, Dr. Millstein combines surgical expertise with a personal, attentive style that makes patients feel truly cared for.
Patients describe him as kind, clear, and highly skilled—someone who listens first, explains thoroughly, and guides them through the recovery process with confidence. His team is equally known for their warmth and professionalism, creating a care experience that’s both top-tier and deeply human.
Outside the OR, Dr. Millstein is a dedicated dad to two teenagers, and likes to stay active—often on the basketball court or ski slopes.
Bring what matters to you
What do people remember about knee replacement care? These patient accounts mention the procedure in their own words, from the first conversation to the details they chose to share afterward.
In their own words
These are individual experiences. A topic mention does not establish who performed a procedure, medical suitability or a typical result.
This collection shows written reviews rated 4 or 5 stars that mention knee replacement. You can read every rating and written review on the full clinician profile.
17 written reviews
Highest rated first · Newest within each rating
Dr. Millstein is an amazing person, especially for a surgeon. He is personable, friendly and east to relate to. Also a great surgeon. I had a knee replacement with him and 6 months later, my knee is as good as new.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
I saw Dr Millstein for my left total knee replacement over a year ago…from booking my surgery, his staff and the doctor himself, it’s 5 star ⭐️’s from me. I’m even booking my next knee replacement - other side - next month!
Eric S. Millstein, MD
I had a total knee replacement with Dr. Millstein in April of 2024 and he and his team are superb! They are great! Although the surgery itself was my most painful surgery, the process of my pre-op, the surgery itself and post op were fantastic! I need my other knee done and I will have Dr Millstein do the surgery!! His office staff are amazing! So helpful with everything!
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Great experience with Dr. Millstein. I had a consultation for a knee replacement. Would highly recommend him.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Dr. Eric Millstein is awesome! I had a right knee replacement and a right shoulder replacement this year and I would do it again. So happy about my results, and the attention Dr. Millstein gives. His candor helps you to trust what he says and the end results are proof that his word, expertise and experience absolutely can be trusted.. He is the Best.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Dr Millstein is very nice , professional. Remembers me. Office is clean. Staff is friendly and helpful. I had a total knee replacement and he was very honest about what to expect. I am still healing but walking without a cane in 6 weeks. Everyone is different.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Dr Millstein is the best!!! From the initial consultation, thru knee replacement surgery and recovery it has been such a positive experience. His staff is also amazing!!!
Eric S. Millstein, MD
I saw Dr Millstein for a second opinion on a knee replacement surgery. His recommendation was very straight forward and direct. He gave me exactly the information I needed to move forward with the knee replacement.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Everyone is friendly and knowledgeable. Dr. Millstein is a great doctor. I had a full knee replacement and I am very happy with the results!
Eric S. Millstein, MD
This was my first experience with any doctor other than my GP. I had a ton of anxiety going in but Dr.Millstein was personable and patient as we discussed my issue and he assuaged any anxiety I had surrounding my visit and his recommendation going forward . He sat and listened patiently as I went through the list of questions I had and made sure I was satisfied with the answers before I left (I had convinced myself he was going to tell me I needed a knee replacement!!!). The experience was better than I even imagined it would be - and I get to keep my knee - lol.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Dr. Millstein is a wonderful doctor. I went to him for knee replacement surgery, as well as for his opinion regarding rotator cuff surgery. He suggested that no surgery was necessary at this time. I trust Dr. M and his opinions.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
This is wonderful office. Everyone smiles when you come in. But most important is the quality of care. i have always felt that Dr. Millstein is an extremely skilled practitioner , attention to the patient's questions, and attempts to answer directly, snd honestly. My husband had knee replacement several year ago, and had some physical therapy to assist in the recovery, and the Physical Therapist said he could be a poster child fort this kind of surgery. A perfect job!!!! Very fine Doctor.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Best possible outcomes because of Dr. Millstein! I couldn't be happier with my recent knee replacement that Dr. Millstein performed. And - I'm only 2 weeks out from the surgery! He was very upfront with the pros and cons for me. I have always felt that he truly cares about me and my situation. I have Lupus and arthritis and have deliberated the decision for the replacement for almost 10 years. I was told for the first few that I was too young for it at the time. I'm still technically too young since there is a possibility I'll have to have another one someday. But - Dr. M never pushed the surgery on me. In fact, he told me two years ago, that he wouldn't do it for "aggravating" only when it became unbearable. That happened this year when I was held back from almost all of the activities I have enjoyed my whole life. It was time. And I couldn't be more pleased with the results. I was a bit concerned at the start - because I got a UTI in the hospital and had to stay on a little longer. But - my care from Dr. Millstein and the residents on call took amazing care of me, gave me a lot of attention and clearly explained the issues and risks. I came home in fine shape, and was off to rehab! Best decision I've made regarding my health in a long time. I can't wait to ski, hike, bike and play in the coming months!
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Dr. Millstein performed a knee replacement on my right knee on 5/17/17. He operated on my left knee 2 1/2 years ago. Both surgeries went extremely well, and my recuperation has been excellent both times. He is very caring, and listens to you. I live in Palm Desert, but he is worth the long drive. Also as a bonus, my scars look better than others I have seen. I recommend him highly. Please don't review this business if you received a freebie for writing this review, or if you're cOnfnnected in any way to the owner or employees.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Did my knee replacement surgery and i was up and moving sooner, stronger and better than anyone that I know. Good guy, the kind of Dr you recommend without a second thought.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
(This review is WAY late, but more than worth reading!) I had massive knee/joint pain. After meeting with several orthopedists and finding no real rapport or confidence with them, I met with Dr. Millstein. My knees instantly knew they'd found their soulmate! It was clear from arthroscopic surgery I was walking on borrowed time, not to mention being freaked out at the thought of knee replacement. When I'm nervous, I ask a lot of questions, and by "a lot" I mean "a lot MORE than a lot." Not only did he answer each and every one, but went the extra light year and laughed at my jokes (unlike most physicians, who usually threaten to charge me extra). (As they say, I can be a "problem patient.") When it came time to replace my left knee, I went willingly. (He's been kind enough never to mention that in my about-to-enter-dreamland fog, I think I asked him for a date! Oy!) A few days at Cedars-Sinai and a few months of PT and I was walking a zillion times better than I ever had! In fact, a few months later, he replaced my right knee, which I have very comfortably crossed over my left as I type this several years later (I told you I was way late with this). For a while, he no longer accepted my insurance, and I respect him for that, because I felt he was vastly undercompensated by said company. And I am willing to pay the extra "out-of-plan" cost to see him, because I feel 100% comfortable in his care, not to mention that of his nurse, Nancy (how she puts up with me I'll never know either)! In short, if you don't have a leg to stand on, you should see Dr. Millstein! (And no, he didn't laugh at that one either!) In all seriousness, he IS the best!
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Dr. Millstein : Babyboomer Athletes Best Friend. Dr. Millstein's no nonsense approach to evaluating my knee problem (swelling from past surgeries), resulted in a spot-on diagnosis. No knee replacement needed (as other Dr's have suggested). He simply said," You dont need me - you need good Physical Theropy." Millstein directed me to his website and suggested me to use one of his Theropists. Following his instructions, a Theropist was chosen. The rest is history. My knee is now strong and fully oprational. Dr. Millstein changed my life. F. K.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
A little more understanding
Knee
A useful knee replacement consultation explains the diagnosis, the options, and what the operation may change in your life. Compare the whole plan, including rehabilitation, support at home, and access to help after surgery.
Read the guideKnee
The choice depends on which parts of your knee are affected and whether the remaining joint can support the result.
Read the guide
